Opera  , symphony  , all  sorts  of  instrumental  and  vocal  music  but  not  
chamber  music .sx   His  reading  was  considerable  in  classical  and  English  
and  French  literature .sx   He  knew  Dickens  by  heart  , but  ranked  " Vanity  
Fair  " of  Thackeray  the  greatest  English  novel  of  his  period .sx   He  was  
sceptical  of  contemporary  writing  as  he  was  of  the  latest  composition .sx   
I  guessed  that  in  politics  he  was  a  conservative-  with  freedom  to  be  
against  the  Government  whatever  its  colour  or  party .sx   He  loved  good  
food  and  good  wine  , and  his  cigars  , but  not  to  excess .sx   No  alcohol  had  
power  over  his  quick  balanced  mind .sx   I  was  taken  aback  when  he  
reflected  one  day  on  his  career :sx   " Do  you  know  , I  sometimes  wonder  if  
I  haven't  wasted  myself  to  some  degree  by  giving  myself  almost  wholly  
to  music .sx   For  music  does  not  ever  encourage  abstract  thinking  or  
pungency  of  comment  or  dialectical  agility .sx   Perhaps  I  was  really  born  
for  the  legal  profession .sx   " 
I  pointed  out  that  in  music  he  was  an  absolutist  , that  he  had  no  
patience  with  music  which  carried  extra-musical  significances  , and  
that  also  he  had  no  patience  with  conductors  , or  any  other  performer  , 
who  found  an  argument  , a  dialectic  or  the  faintest  hint  of  a  
metaphysic  in  music .sx   He  didn't  seek  beyond  the  notes  and  the  forms  of  
music  for  some  inner  meaning .sx   Often  he  gave  me  the  impression  that  he  
was  not  so  much  the  " possessed  " artist  in  music  as  the  connoisseur  , 
collecting  composers  as  he  collected  his  furniture  and  plate .sx   He  
fondled  music  , handled  it  carefully  and  dotingly-  unless  it  was  of  
the  sort  that  protested  too  much  , assaulted  fastidiousness  of  taste  
and  sensitivity .sx   " Mahler ?sx   Wagner ?sx   Bruckner ?sx   " he  would  say  , 
cross-examining  me .sx   " They  are  not  civilised .sx   Mahler  exposes  his  
self-pity  ; Wagner  , though  a  tremendous  genius  , gorged  music  , like  a  
German  who  overeats .sx   And  Bruckner  was  a  hobbledehoy  who  had  no  style  
at  all .sx   All  three  of  them  knew  nothing  about  poise  or  modesty .sx   Even  
Beethoven  thumped  the  tub  ; the  Ninth  symphony  was  composed  by  a  kind  
of  Mr.  Gladstone  of  music .sx   " 
All  that  doesn't  imply  that  he  was  at  all  short  of  masculinity  , 
red  corpuscles .sx   He  could  ride  roughshod  over  his  dislikes  , people  or  
compositions .sx   Given  the  impulse  from  the  right  source  , his  musical  
energy-  ( his  physical  energy  too !sx )-  concentrated  into  artistic  and  
proportionate  shapes .sx   His  interpretation  of  the  " Requiem  Mass  " of  
Berlioz  has  seldom  been  equalled  for  emotional  intensity  and  
sure-minded  control  of  the  outlines .sx   His  temperament  and  intelligence  
responded  more  readily  to  Latin  than  to  German  stimulations  , aesthetic  
or  other .sx   Sometimes  he  gave  his  conscience  a  holiday .sx   At  Liverpool  
an  inordinately  heavy  programme  was  goading  the  orchestra  to  open  
rebellion  , especially  as  Sir  Thomas  prolonged  the  interval .sx   The  
concert  was  taking  place  on  the  eve  of  the  world's  greatest  
steeplechase .sx   When  Sir  Thomas  returned  to  the  platform  he  immediately  
sensed  the  temper  of  his  players-  and  the  next  work  to  tackle  was  the  
" great  C  major  " symphony  of  Schubert .sx   Sir  Thomas  extended  his  
arms  , the  baton  militant .sx   " Now  , gentlemen  , " he  said  , " now  for  the  
Grand  National .sx   " The  performance  was  magnificent .sx   One  gust  of  his  
humour  dispersed  all  animosities .sx   

He  was  not  , as  I  say  , liked  or  admired  by  everybody  while  he  was  
the  spruce  disdainful  Mr.  Thomas  Beecham .sx   He  was  suspected  of  
Dandyism  and  , in  fact  , he  was  the  last  of  the  Dandies .sx   He  kept  
audiences  waiting  at  his  concerts .sx   In  Manchester  , during  one  of  his  
opera  seasons  there  , he  kept  the  audience  waiting  half  an  hour  for  a  
performance  of  Isidore  de  Lara's  " Nai"l .sx   " In  those  years  his  
manners  at  a  symphony  concert  did  not  appeal  to  the  taste  of  the  
Establishment  of  British  music .sx   The  music  critic  of  the  " Manchester  
" -  Samuel  Langford-  took  him  to  task  on  account  of  his  
acrobatic  gestures  as  he  conducted .sx   At  one  concert  his  baton  flew  
from  his  hand  and  nearly  impaled  the  first  trombone .sx   Moreover  , he  was  
suspected  of  " amateurism"-  long  before  Toscanini  actually  called  
him  an  " amateur .sx   " A  complex  character !sx -  Falstaff  , Puck  and  
Malvolio  all  mixed  up  , each  likely  to  overwhelm  the  others .sx   Witty  , 
then  waggish  ; supercilious  , then  genial  , kindly  , and  sometimes  cruel  ; 
an  artist  in  affectation  yet  somehow  always  himself .sx   Lancashire  in  
his  bones  , yet  a  man  of  the  world .sx   Rachmaninoff  told  a  friend  that  he  
was  unhappy  about  a  forthcoming  concert .sx   " The  conductor-  
so-and-so-  he  has  no  temperament .sx   It  is  always  so  in  England .sx   Too  
many  the  English  gentlemens .sx   " " But  , " his  friend  pointed  out  
" last  year  you  said  your  concert  with  Sir  Thomas  Beecham  was  one  of  
the  best  and  happiest  of  your  life .sx   " " Ah  , " rejoined  
Rachmaninoff  , " but  Sir  Thomas  is  not  one  of  your  English  
gentlemens .sx   " 
In  the  prime  of  his  life  and  career  , Sir  Thomas  was  as  closely  
associated  with  Manchester  as  with  London  or  anywhere  else .sx   During  
the  1914-1918  war  he  kept  the  city's  music  alive  by  the  sparkle  , 
vivacity  , and  sway  of  his  personality .sx   His  concerts  with  the  Halle@2  
Orchestra  and  his  opera  productions  in  Quay  Street  elevated  the  city  
far  above  provincial  levels .sx   Until  he  dominated  the  scene  
Manchester's  music  was  mainly  of  German  extraction  , as  we  have  noted  
already  and  will  probably  note  again .sx   Richter  had  not  served  
Manchester  in  a  backward-looking  way .sx   He  conducted  all  the  symphonic  
poems  of  Richard  Strauss  in  one  season  at  a  time  when-  6mirabile  
dictu !sx -  Strauss  was  considered  as  " modern  , " iconoclast  and  
unmusical  as  any  later  " nberg  , Webern  , or  Boulez .sx   Stanford  went  
so  far  as  to  compose  a  musical  satire  of  Strauss-  " An  Ode  to  
Discord .sx   " Ernest  Newman  abjured  us  to  listen  to  Strauss  
" horizontally  " while  the  battle-section  of  " Ein  Heldenleben  " 
was  played .sx   It  is  nowadays  generally  forgotten  that  Strauss  came  to  
renown  or  notoriety  in  this  country  exclusively  on  the  strength  of  his  
symphonic  poems .sx   Outside  London  " Der  Rosenkavalier  , " 
" Salome  " and  " Elektra  " were  little  known  here .sx   
But  Richter's  enterprise  ended  with  the  " progressive  German  
composers .sx   " It  is  true  that  he  was  the  first  conductor  to  put  Elgar  
on  the  musical  map  , the  reason  being  , I  fancy  , that  in  Elgar  he  heard  
here  and  there  the  echo  of  his  own  native  musical  language .sx   To  a  
deputation  of  Manchester's  youthful  6avant  garde  , demanding  
some  representation  at  the  Halle@2  Concerts  of  modern  French  music  , 
Richter  replied  , " 3Zthere  iss  no  mod'n  F-french  Musik .sx   " 
Beecham  brought  pagan  allurements  to  the  Halle@2  , 
" classical"-  Scene  =4  of  Act  =2  of  Delius's  " A  Village  
Romeo  and  Juliet  , " Stravinsky's  " Firebird  " suite  , Borodin's  
" Polovtsian  Dances  , " all  in  the  same  programme .sx   Between  the  two  
wars  he  naturally  modulated  to  a  conversation  indicative  of  the  fact  
that  he  was  now  old  enough  to  put  behind  him  childish  things .sx   But  
never  would  he  desert  Delius .sx   On  the  " classical  " side  he  
discovered  Haydn  for  English  ears .sx   He  even  proposed  introducing  to  
Manchester  Stravinsky's  " Le  Sacre  du  " ;  but  the  
orchestral  parts  went  astray .sx   The  Halle@2  Concerts  Committee  asked  
for  a  substitute  piece  at  short  notice .sx   Beecham  suggested  a  Beethoven  
symphony .sx   No  ; already  the  season's  programme  had  included  enough  
Beethoven .sx   They  asked  Sir  Thomas  to  conduct  Mendelssohn's  
" Italian  " symphony .sx   " Impossible  , " replied  Sir  Thomas  , " quite  
impossible  , with  only  two  rehearsals .sx   " " But  , " argued  the  
committee  , " you  were  content  with  two  rehearsals  for  'Le  
Sacre .sx '  " " Quite  so  , " said  Sir  Thomas  blandly  , " I  could  play  
'Le  Sacre'  well  enough  after  two  rehearsals .sx   For  the  
'Italian'  symphony  five  at  least  is  absolutely  necessary .sx   " 

His  creation  of  the  London  Philharmonic  Orchestra  absorbed  him  
and  his  time  in  the  1930s  ; consequently  his  appearances  in  Manchester  
became  intermittent .sx   After  the  resignation  of  Sir  Hamilton  Harty  in  
1933  as  the  permanent  conductor  of  the  Halle@2  Concerts  , the  
orchestra  declined  in  its  ensemble .sx   Another  permanent  conductor  was  
needed  , but  the  Halle@2  Society  were  reluctant  to  appoint  one  for  
fear  of  losing  Sir  Thomas's  presence  altogether .sx   And  Sir  Thomas  
scared  the  society  by  attacking  the  B.B.C.  , forecasting  that  
broadcasting  would  keep  people  away  from  concerts .sx   As  critic  of  the  
" Manchester  Guardian  , " in  Manchester  in  the  1930s  , I  pointed  out  
week  by  week  the  falling  away  of  the  orchestra  in  unity  of  style .sx   But  
my  friendship  with  Sir  Thomas  , resumed  soon  after  our  argument  about  
his  " cuts  " in  " Der  Rosenkavalier  , " was  now  apparently  
unclouded .sx   I  was  vastly  surprised  and  amused  to  learn  from  Michael  
Kennedy's  history  of  the  Halle@2  Concerts  that  in  1937  Sir  Thomas  
wrote  to  the  society  stating  " that  he  refused  to  conduct  any  concert  
to  which  Mr.  Neville  Cardus  was  invited .sx   " 6Et  tu  , Sir  
Thomas !sx   And  all  the  time  I  imagined  my  notices  were  generously  kind  
about  him .sx   Never  did  he  refer  to  this  letter  to  the  Halle@2  Society  , 
demanding  my  excommunication  , at  any  of  my  subsequent  meetings  with  
him  , not  even  during  our  day  by  day  , night  by  night  expressions  of  
brotherly  love  in  Australia .sx   
It  was  round  about  1931  that  he  told  me  he  was  about  to  form  a  
new  orchestra  in  London .sx   " But  where  , " I  asked  , " where  do  you  hope  
to  find  the  players ?sx -  the  B.B.C.  Orchestra  has  taken  the  
best .sx   " " Maybe  , " he  admitted  " the  B.B.C.  has  indeed  
attracted  the  best  known  instrumentalists  of  Great  Britain .sx   But  
you'll  see !sx   " In  1932  the  Royal  Philharmonic  Orchestra  played  for  
the  first  time  at  the  Queen's  Hall .sx   The  performance  of  the  
" Carnaval  Romain  " overture  of  Berlioz  was  staggeringly  
brilliant .sx   A  highly  finished  performance  of  Mozart's  " Prague  " 
symphony  almost  jerked  me  from  my  seat  when  Sir  Thomas  brought  in  the  
D  major  principal  theme  , after  the  introduction  , at  the  same  adagio  
tempo  , instead  of  allegro .sx   My  notice  next  day  called  for  some  
explanation  of  this  curious  treatment  or  maladjustment .sx   In  his  flat  
in  Hallam  Street  , and  while  he  was  still  in  bed  , working  on  a  score  , 
he  took  away  my  breath  ( not  for  the  first  or  the  last  time  ) by  
assuring  me  that  his  tempo  for  the  main  theme  after  the  introduction  
was  authentic .sx   " You  are  probably  acquainted  only  with  the  published  
score .sx .  but  I  have  seen  the  original  manuscript  written  by  Mozart's  
own  hand .sx .  " All  the  same  , the  next  time  he  conducted  the  
" Prague  " symphony  the  theme  in  question  was  allegro  all  right  and  
unmistakably .sx   He  was  in  a  word  , capable  de  tout !sx   
Apart  from  some  piano  lessons  in  boyhood  he  was  self-taught .sx   
He  states  the  contrary  in  his  biography  , " A  Mingled  Chime  , " where  
he  writes  , " In  public  accounts  of  my  career  has  frequently  appeared  
the  assertion  that  I  am  almost  entirely  self-taught  and  , beginning  as  
a  rank  amateur  , have  attained  a  professional  status  with  some  
difficulty  after  a  long  and  painful  novitiate .sx   Nothing  could  be  more  
remote  from  the  truth .sx   It  is  possible  that  at  the  age  of  twenty  I  
might  have  failed  to  answer  some  of  the  questions  in  an  examination  
paper  set  for  boys  of  sixteen  in  a  musical  academy  ; but  probably  I  
should  fail  with  equal  success  to-day  ; and  I  venture  to  say  that  a  
tolerable  number  of  my  most  gifted  colleagues  would  do  no  better .sx   On  
the  other  hand  , owing  to  my  travels  abroad  and  wider  associations  with  
musicians  here  and  there  , my  miscellaneous  fund  of  information  was  
much  more  extensive  than  that  of  others  of  my  age .sx   " For  Sir  Thomas  , 
this  is  positively  " ve .sx   There  was  music  of  sorts  in  his  St.  
Helens  home  ; his  father  practised  music  " as  a  hobby .sx   " Sir  Thomas  
substantially  educated  himself  , as  Elgar  did  , and  Ernest  Newman  and  
Delius  , perhaps  the  most  cultured  and  influential  figures  in  our  
music's  history  since  Purcell .sx   
He  came  down  from  Oxford  after  only  a  year  or  so  there  because  , 
as  he  explained  to  me  , " there  was  no  musical  life  broad  and  humane  
enough .sx   As  for  the  rest  of  my  studies  at  Oxford  , they  were  not  
attractively  conducted .sx   And  I  could  discover  no  mind  or  intelligence  
among  my  fellow  undergraduates  which  didn't  indicate  permanent  
adolescence .sx   In  those  days  , even  to-day  in  fact  , the  average  
University-educated  Englishman  is  a  case  of  arrested  development  , 
emotionally  , aesthetically  and  sexually .sx   " 
His  own  capacity  for  deep  feeling  was  not  often  or  obviously  
hinted  at  in  his  studied  deportment  away  from  the  concert  platform  or  
desk  at  the  opera .sx   He  gave  unmistakable  proof  of  it  in  my  company  
only  once  , during  one  of  the  last  evenings  I  spent  with  him  alone  a  
few  months  after  Lady  Betty's  sudden  death .sx